Hit & Miss

A Reading Group Guide for

Hit & Miss

By Derek Jeter with Paul Mantell

 

Discussion Questions

Chapter 1 – Season of Hope

Derek Jeter has a strong, supportive family structure. Describe and discuss your family structure. How is it similar or different from Derek’s family makeup?

Derek’s parents establish a contract with him to ensure that he succeeds in school and accomplishes his goals. The contract lists several expectations and includes consequences for breaking the rules. Do you have written family expectations or obligations? If not, are they clearly understood? Explain what happens if you do not follow through or violate these rules.

Derek plays an action-packed game of H.O.R.S.E. with his dad on the basketball court that brings out his competitive nature. What activities do you do that inspire your competitive side?

Chapter 2 – Welcome to the Red Sox

Little League Baseball rules are player specific and more restrictive than the Big Leagues. Why do you think they have age and length-of-play limitations?

Playing with a new team or trying out for anything new is always exciting and can also be a little tense. Having a good friend to share the moment helps. How does Vijay, Derek’s close friend, help him through the team’s beginning practice drills?

Chapter 3 – The New Kid

Discuss what friendship means to you. Give some examples. Is it difficult to make friends with a new classmate?

Do you worry about what others will say if you want to be friends with someone who may be new or different from yourself? What do you fear about reaching out to a new friend?

Chapter 4 – If At First You Don’t Succeed . . .

Derek’s attempts to make friends with Dave were rejected at first. What does he do to assure Dave that he really wants to be friends? Have you ever been rejected or ridiculed? How did that make you feel?

Coach Kaufman organized a scrimmage to observe the strengths and weaknesses of his team. How does this type of practice establish camaraderie and team spirit?

Chapter 5 – The House on the Hill

What new sports game did Dave introduce to Derek? How similar is it to baseball? How is it different?

What did Derek learn about his new friend during the visit? What is the structure of Dave’s family and how does it compare to Derek’s?

Chapter 6 – Making Friends, Breaking Rules

Breaking the rules can cause serious consequences. When Derek agreed to ride home with Dave after school without telling anyone where he was going, he broke the rules. What kind of danger could he have faced? Why did his parents have that rule in place?

Discuss a time when you did not follow the rules. What were the results?

Chapter 7 – Play Ball!

Derek was disappointed with his own performance in the first few ball games of the season. What did he do to change or improve? How did he break his batting slump?

Discuss a situation where you tried and failed. How did you feel? What did you do to change or improve the situation?

Chapter 8 – Practice Makes Perfect?

Derek has to study hard to get good grades. How does his rivalry with Gary Parnell, the “smartest kid in fourth grade,” help him to keep his skills sharp?

What are your strong subjects? What subjects are more difficult? Which ones do you enjoy the most? Why?

Why is it important to improve your test scores? What study methods do you use?

Chapter 9 – The Swing Doctor

Practice does make perfect – especially in sports. Derek’s father takes time to offer batting tips to Derek and his two friends, Vijay and Dave. What happened when the boys applied what they were taught?

Chapter 10 – Game On!

Even though Derek goes through a batting slump, Coach Kaufman continues to use Derek to support the team in other ways. How does this affect his performance? What makes you try harder when you are faced with failure?

Vijay and Dave began to improve their performance after receiving coaching advice from Derek’s father. How did this make Derek feel?

Chapter 11 – Patience Pays Off

Sharlee, Derek’s sister, is being bullied at school by an older, more intimidating classmate. Derek’s parents claim that all bullies are cowards. Do you agree with this? Explain your thoughts.

What is your definition of a bully? What do you think causes such bad behavior?

Have you ever been a victim of bullying or known someone who was bullied? What were your reactions?

What will you try to do in the future to prevent bullying?

Chapter 12 – Push Comes to Shove

Sharlee has been suffering through an uncomfortable situation at school. Jimmy Vickers is picking on her, and she has lost some of her sparkling and upbeat personality. What would you do if you were being picked on every day? Would you tell someone? Who would that person be and why?

Derek became very angry when his sister confessed to him that a kid knocked her down, spit on her, and turned the other kids against her. How does Derek handle this situation? Discuss what you would do if she were your baby sister.

Chapter 13 – Breaking Through

Derek must apologize for his own “bullying” behavior. Why was it so hard for Derek to apologize? What were the results? Discuss a time when your behavior required an apology. Do you agree with the punishment that Derek was given?

One of the rules in Derek’s contract is to “Be a Role Model for Sharlee.” Does he live up to this expectation? How?

Chapter 14 – Streak on the Line

Derek learns a critical life lesson when the team’s winning streak is on the line: the game is not over until the last out. Even if it looks bad and you have to go into extra innings, it pays to have hope, work hard, and never give up. Why is this an important lesson?

Can you think of an occasion when you were rewarded for not giving up?

Chapter 15 – On the Edge

Throughout the entire school year, Derek continues to study hard and receives a 93 on his math final, but his taunting classmate Gary Parnell always seems to get a better grade. What happens to Parnell that stops his bragging on the spot? Why does Derek feel justified?

Why were test scores important to Derek?

Sharlee learns that even your enemies can change. How does her relationship with Jimmy Vickers change?

Chapter 16 – Winners Take All

At the end of the playoff game, Derek’s mom encouraged him to see the final game and season results in a different way. What did she say to make him feel better? What do you think about the support she gave?

Chapter 17 – FORE!

Dave and Derek recognized and appreciated the importance of a good coach and mentor. Do you have adults in your life that encourage your endeavors and offer you advice? Describe who they are and how they help you.

Extension Activities

Ask readers to review Derek Jeter’s Ten Life Lessons. They are listed in the front of the book and on his website: http://mlb.mlb.com/players/jeter_derek/kids/handbook.jsp.

CHOOSE A LIFE GOAL

Instruct your students to select one life goal that they have made and ask them to share in writing what they are doing to reach it. Discuss any challenges that may occur to deter them from reaching their goal.

THERE IS NO “I” IN TEAM

Write a 200-word essay on “The Importance of Teamwork.”

JUST IMAGINE A STORY

Read out loud the passages in Hit & Miss regarding the play-by-play events in the championship game. Then ask the students to stand in a large group circle. Toss a softball or Nerf ball to one student in the class and have him or her tell their own play-by-play story of one inning of a baseball game. When the instructor calls “stop” after a brief period, the teller tosses the ball to another student, who picks up the play and continues the story. This ball toss continues until the inning is declared over with three outs.

AN ALTERNATIVE ENDING

The teacher reads aloud from Hit & Miss by Derek Jeter. Refer to pages 113 -133. A classroom activity is assigned to write a different reaction and result to the encounter with Sharlee’s bully. Divide the class into pairs and have them share with each other their own story ending. Allow the pairs to share or role-play their “new” ending in class, if time permits.

(Note: Remind them to consider changing the setting, the dialogue, the number of characters involved, or/and the response from the adults) Refer to National Core Arts Standards http://www.nationalartsstandards.org/ -- theatre standards.

READING COYOTE

Read Coyote by Gerald McDermott to the class; discuss vocabulary (ravens, coyote, mesa) and setting (desert). Ask students to write their own original folktale based on a similar incident using these or similar animal characters. Discuss how Coyote’s story fits the same pattern as the bullying incident(s) in Jeter’s Hit & Miss. Classroom discussion follows the reading assignment.

Objective: Based on Coyote by Gerald McDermott, a tale inspired by Coyote stories of the desert southwest, this project requires students to listen, respond, write, speak, think about cause and effect, predict outcomes – and to think about what happens to bullies!

Discussion questions:

What animal does Coyote see?

What does Coyote want from that animal?

What does Coyote threaten to do to the animal?

How does the animal trick Coyote into a) making him believe he’s getting what he wants, and b) getting even with him for being such a bully?

What happens to Coyote at the end of the story?

What happens to Sharlee and her “bully” at the end of Hit & Miss?

SHARING STORY SCENARIOS 

The classroom teacher asks students to sit in a circle in the classroom with an empty chair in the center of the room. A game of musical chairs is introduced using the song “Take Me Out to the Ballgame”. When the music begins, students will begin to walk slowly around the circle of chairs and grab a seat each time the music is stopped. (Be sure there is one less chair than students forcing one student to be left standing without a chair). This student will then sit in the middle “hot” seat. The teacher then pulls out a baseball glove (use a catcher’s mitt or a pitcher’s glove) that has several Story Scenarios inside. (See scenarios below). The student is asked to discuss what they would do if they were confronted with the selected situation. After they have shared their idea, the music begins again. Then another student is selected to sit in the seat and discuss a bullying scenario. Continue as time permits.

 

Bullying Scenario #1:

A school bully has just dissed your new outfit. What is your response?

Bullying Scenario...